The dichotomy of violence in today's culture.
Is the American pop culture more violent now than it was 50
years ago? This question came to my mind
I as watched a social media post of two high school aged girls fighting in a
neighborhood park. Upon pondering that question, I came to the realization that
our society is somewhat hypocritical in if you compare what we preach/teach and
what we consume. 50 years ago corporal
punishment was a common and socially accepted form of discipline/punishment most
American households. In contrast to
that, the amount of violence actually shown in TV and movies was far less than
what we see today.
Today gratuitous violence is the norm in television and
movies. I'm sure that the producers of these programs argue that it is fueled
by consumer demand. The part that I find
interesting though, is that we have zero tolerance policies in schools for violence.
It is no long socially acceptable to
spank or use corporal punishment with
our children and there is big movement
to eradicate all bullying. I'm not
writing to make the point that the aforementioned should be embraced, but more
so to shine some light on what seems to be a bit of a contradiction in American
Pop culture. We say we are anti-violence
yet mixed martial arts fights are growing exponentially in popularity while it
is a far more violent sport than boxing is. We have violent video games, we
have social media post of violent acts that go viral. This all begs the question in my
opinion. Are we "really" as
anti-violence and we may claim to be.
I would say we are a much more violent culture. We have even begun to embrace female
violence. I'm not implying that women
should not have the right fight professionally if they choose to do so. Instead, I am pointing out the shift in our
culture's appetite for violence as manifested by us now consuming a women's
fight where that would have been such a taboo in the not so distant past. All the while we are make stiffer laws and applying
more social pressure against all types of violence, whether it be in schools,
at home or anywhere else. Bottom line is
that we don't practice what we preach!
Interesting topic. You hit on a strong point in noting the paradoxical way Americans teach people to be non-violent yet happily consume violence in entertainment. However, you should be asking more questions as to why this is so. If Americans are culturally less accepting of violence in their personal lives than they have been in the past why has the consumption of violence in entertainment risen?
ReplyDeleteMr. Felix.